OK, I am more than aware that it's a logical fallacy to argue from the specific to the general. I'm going to do it anyway, so you've been warned. Our world would be much better if instead of "SPOILER ALERT" in every stupid article on a book or movie we'd use "LOGICAL FALLACY" in op-ed pieces, radio talk shows, and cable "news" propagandist channels.
But first, an aside; I was trudging through a workout yesterday at the gym (because, at my age, one simply trudges like a dull-witted beast of burden through such things) when the cable channels lit up with news that Col. Ghaddafi was about to be deposed. Life is a loop, a wheel, an endless run of river...I was similarly situated 8 years earlier watching US troops topple Saddam Hussein in Iraq.
Alas, Mr. Ghaddafi remains in power as of this morning. But the sands in the hourglass are dwindling fast.
I'm pretty sure if you're reading this that you know about the 49er-Raider brawl over the weekend. And, if you're a Facebook pal o'mine you might have watched the video I posted from the Ravens-Chiefs game wherein some Raven fans start shoving a Chiefs fan around. To those sorry instances I'll toss in the Dodgers-Giants fight in LA that left a San Francisco Giants fan hospitalized with brain injuries. Oh, and last season on my way back from a Redskins-Eagles game (the Monday nighter where Vick went apesh*t on the Redskins?) I witnessed at least 2 such brawls....that appeared to be between Redskin fans. Several years ago I saw Baltimore fans at a Ravens-Jaguars game start to menace and shove around a guy in a Jacksonville jersey. My children and I were threatened by Oriole fans because we had the audacity to cheer for the Red Sox at Oriole Park a few years ago. By the 3rd inning my kid weren't standing up to cheer for the Sox; when I asked why they said they were scared of the guys behind us (I'd been ignoring them). They kept it up for a few innings and got bored I guess.
My point in ennumerating them is that these are not isolated incidents. Yes, they're committed by guys (mostly) who are: 1) most likely drunk; and 2)probably the type that gets into these kind of scrapes regularly.
And, in the Bay Area brawl last weekend, well those guys look like the type---right? Yet, watch the Ravens clip (it's on youtube). There's a kid who looks like your average DMB/Phish fan dressed in the uniform of the Frat Boy (yet in a purple shirt, why purple?) who decides it's OK to walk up to the Chiefs fan and start shoving him around.
There's no audio, perhaps there was verbal provocation but I doubt it. And, for his trouble, the young fella gets knocked out; his buddies were numerous though and they...uh...defended his honor.
If you've been to games you've probably heard and seen this. Anger. Threats. There's a line between good-natured "Ah, get outta here ya bum" when another team's fan is cheering on his team and the outright hostility that you sometimes see. I'm not trying to be disingenuous here, I realize that millions of us go to these games every year and that out of those millions we're seeing maybe 100 such incidents (if that) a year.
But what the hell are people so angry about? That a guy roots for another team? That he/she is different than you?
There's a parallel to our national discourse on politics and policy. On the left we have MSNBC and some of the CNN shows that espouse liberalism; and on the right we have Fox. CNN tries to straddle the line but leans left. The talking heads employed by all of those networks exalt their agendas over the agendas of the "other." Newspapers have been doing this for years.
At some point some genius decided that it was more important to present the public with "news pieces" that appealed to our emotions. And, at some point, they also discovered that we as a country had become lazy. We like to read and hear "news" items that reflect and reinforce what we already believe to be true. The basic function of news as a mere recitation of fact is nearly extinct, we have no one to blame for this except for our own laziness as people.
That all starts, I'm arguing, with the fact that we don't challenge ourselves. We surround ourselves with like-minded people. We watch and read things that reinforce and reflect our own beliefs and prejudices. We spin nice little cocoons that shield us from anything that would threaten our reality.
And, when we feel that cocoon is threatened, there's anger and hostility.
Look at this morning's news. In the Washington Post there's a guy lampooning Governor Perry for his stance on global warming. Rush Limbaugh is using the new Oreo cookie to make an overtly racist Obama joke (which he'll get away with, for reasons only the devil knows). Democrats demonize Republicans and vice versa.
There's barely a discussion of policy pros and cons, there's simply: "This is what I think. You're stupid and wrong if you think otherwise and you're ideas are bad for America."
In other words, "you don't root for my team and so you deserve to be punched."
This country is a good place to live and has good people in it, but we're nothing more than that. We're not Egyptians or Canannites who believe that God (or gods) granted us a Divine right to exercise dominion over the globe we were fortunate enough to be born on. What sets us apart from other countries has been our ability as a people to forge common ground.
Sometime in the 1980's they started self-esteem as part of the educational curricula in schools, which I thought was rubbish. I do wonder, sometimes, if the attitudes of young people have been warped into consequences that weren't intended by the authors of that curricula. When you're convinced that you're the greatest ever and life doesn't fall into place as you'd hoped....when you make yourself the center of the universe in your own mind and no one recognizes your self-appointed greatness......are fear, anger, and fury the only rational response.?
Or....hell....it could just be the beer.